Is Organic Really Better? Healthy Food or Trendy Scam?

Share
HTML-code
  • Published: 13 January 2019
  • The first 1000 people to use this link will get a 2 month free trial of skillshare: skl.sh/kurzgesagt5

    Organic food is a huge trend: it promises a healthier and better life. But can Organic food really live up to the expectations or is it just baloney?

    Sources:
    sites.google.com/view/sourcesorganic/

    Support us on Patreon so we can make more videos (and get cool stuff in return): patreon.com/Kurzgesagt?ty=h

    Steady: steadyhq.com/de/kurzgesagt
    Merchandise:  shop.kurzgesagt.org
    Newsletter: eepurl.com/cRUQxz
    Facebook: bit.ly/1NB6U5O
    Twitter: bit.ly/2DDeT83
    Instagram: bit.ly/2DEN7r3
    Discord: discord.gg/cB7ycdv

    The Voice of Kurzgesagt:
    Steve Taylor: voice-pool.com/en/english/

    The music of the video here:
    Soundcloud: bit.ly/2kqh1a8
    Bandcamp: bit.ly/2y2YLbW
    Facebook: bit.ly/2qW6bY4

    THANKS A LOT TO OUR LOVELY PATRONS FOR SUPPORTING US:Alberto, Rain Babauta, michael mckinnie, Zabeer Hossain, Patrick Belfry, GeF, Jaden Lem, Cathulhu, Clement Kuo, Kinga Stroińska, Guido Jossels, Damon Bradley, Filip Cerny, Sebastian Kroll, Foxyboxes, Karsten Müller-Bier, Geoff French, Solara570, Aaron Massey, Lee Pomelie, Joel TJ, Maurice Nilles, Joseph Hutchins, Jaski, Ben Lutz, Lukas Zivny, Joonas Javanainen, Will Watts, Gardan, Jorge Pérez, MadByte, Stephen Grose, Nikolas Heberer, Kirby Glover, xhantus404, Benjamin Chalker, ParallaxCore, Turtle, Tom Hutton, Nico Meyer, Anthony Pardini-Bielecki, Laura Starkey, Jai Fox, Victor Hernandez, Ainsley, Revan Tair, Maciej Brzyski, Teemu Leisti, Miguel Diaz, Xierumeng, berk ozdilek, Damien Cassan-Barnel, Michael Kretzschmar, Angelos Manousaridis, Nicolas Molin, Christiaan Magre, onno424, bugcaptor, Aidan Rooney, Marcos Garcia, Chris Thompson, Colm Foley, Ramsey Elbasheer

    Help us caption & translate this video!youtube.com/timedtext_cs_panel?c=UCsXVk37bltHxD1rDPwtNM8Q&tab=2

Comments • 17 790

  • Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell

    Sources: https://sites.google.com/view/sourcesorganic/

    • royaldarkness
      royaldarkness  4 weeks back

      @Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell

      hey, can you or someone answer this ?, although you say that organic farming that make those organic fruit/vegetable nutritious are nearly the same as the normal farming way today, but a few day ago a news that I watch (on the world topic) say that the nutritious over the year are beginning to become less, that in the past (around ww 1 or before) one apple is enough, but now you need to eat around 20 apple (not literally, but a bit close enough) just to get enough nutritious there, something to do with the way modern farming (not organic one) make the farm land more starving of nutritious for the plant to consume, and they harvest almost right away when the plant just ripe, so not allow much time for the plant to absorb much nutritious at all, that what I remember the news said about
      so in the end, do the organic fruit/vegetable are more nutritious than the normal fruit ?

    • Giorgos Papachristos
      Giorgos Papachristos  1 months back

      Greek subs please...

    • Menos The Name
      Menos The Name  2 months back

      @Atal Gyawali Mighty be placebo, but I totalt agree

    • Atal Gyawali
      Atal Gyawali  2 months back

      Hay and about the taste, organic fruits tastes much better the inorganic.

  • Coen Bakker
    Coen Bakker  7 hours back

    What about food from perma vs mono culture? Would be a nice topic for a future video.

    • Dinoboy
      Dinoboy  16 hours back

      Why do people think GMOs are bad? They make the plants more efficient and do not have any negative effects on the environment.

      • Arcas Yard
        Arcas Yard  1 days back

        So that's how Snow White was poisoned...lol

        • Toon Boy
          Toon Boy  1 days back

          Manure is just bone meal

          Prove me wrong

          • Cassie Sevigny
            Cassie Sevigny  2 days back

            This video isn’t totally wrong, but leaves a lot out. I’m surprised the discussion of environmental impact totally neglected effects on soil health, or that synthetic fertilizer is made from natural gas, or that departing from the conventional focus on high yield monoculture was the whole point of organic. While productivity of an individual crop may go down, organic farners can intercrop - reduce the depletion of soil nutrients while simultantaneously diversifying production (and risk of crop failure). Yes, organic production is entirely about ideology bc it was founded by people disillusioned by conventional ag, which is heavily subsidized, dependent on inputs & ever-“advancing” technologies for farmers to invest in, and characterized by extreme concentration of power on all levels, which makes it hard for farners, especially small ones, to survive.

            • Julie Frommes
              Julie Frommes  2 days back

              why are you calling non organic "conventional".... organic IS conventional and GMO and Monsanto seeds/pesticides are new fangled and not proven safe. . not conventional. ☺peace☺

              • Daily Tofu
                Daily Tofu  2 days back

                Organic food are fresh already picked up, I find them much more fresh, just imagine not using pesticide, *no air pollution yey*

                • Random05
                  Random05  2 days back

                  At 0:53, is the food and stuff from Parks and Rec?

                  • Plamen Dimov
                    Plamen Dimov  3 days back

                    sorry.. first dislike for the channel from me...

                  • Zack The Savage
                    Zack The Savage  4 days back

                    4:15 if plants were that cute thanos would just SNAP every meat tbh LOOK AT THAT CARROT!
                    But the issue is i would cry my stomach (yes stomach) out if i ate it unless if it WANTED to. Well there is a reason why some things exist and some don- İ DONT CARE İ CARE BOUT CUTE CARROTS!

                    • Drewski
                      Drewski  4 days back

                      How do you get "dislikes" for good information? Smh

                      • Emil Edlund
                        Emil Edlund  3 days back

                        I would guess it is from climate radicalists, and people who dislike Kurzegesagt on principle due to some other video.

                    • Richard Pavuk
                      Richard Pavuk  4 days back

                      aww :-D

                      • V T
                        V T  6 days back

                        It is healthier

                      • AZ DC
                        AZ DC  6 days back

                        Best solution is to support local farmers.

                        • David S
                          David S  6 days back

                          "Organic" or not, anyone can label anything organic. There's no one regulating it.

                          • Ian Lairmore
                            Ian Lairmore  6 days back

                            7:22 that sword is from adventure time

                            • Ian Lairmore
                              Ian Lairmore  6 days back

                              0:13 do you know who that lemon is?




                              hint: its from adventure time

                            • Olav Hansen
                              Olav Hansen  7 days back

                              @kurzgesagt thank you for actually keeping a level head, saying that organic or bio isn't better. I study plant sciences and when we did some calculations we got less emission/kg produce, with less land needed. I don't think bio labels are good, I think the rules for everyone should change. If the right rules are generated, there is no use for the bio label. I live in the netherlands, perhaps the forefront with regards to farming, and I have this note about the most bs rule in bio food: it must be produced on full ground. To someone unspecialized that might sound like it is logical, but for the current state of agriculture it is utter rubbish. There's hydroponic systems using up all the waste that's a side product from fish. You'd think I just mentioned the major reason but that is a sidenote on a small scale. there are currently greenhouses that are carbon neutral (solar energy+heat pumps), yet they are unable to put on any "bio" label even though they were harvested carbon neutrally, without the use of pesticides (most greenhouses don't even get infections, so there is no need for fungicides). As with pests, there is a reason why you can buy ladybugs on amazon, it's used in greenhouses to combat pests.

                              • Cruzyfied
                                Cruzyfied  1 weeks back

                                I believe animal produce should be viewed seperately, because organic food has much higher standards for animal welfare. This often leads to smaller farms with less animals. At least from a moral perspective, there is a big plus for organic.

                                • Shelby DU
                                  Shelby DU  1 weeks back

                                  Has anyone noticed that the lemon at 0:09 look's like Lemongrab and the Grass Sword appears at 7:16?

                                  • Alfonso Gallardo
                                    Alfonso Gallardo  1 weeks back

                                    But how do we tell the difference bettween organic and regular?

                                    • The Thinking Being
                                      The Thinking Being  1 weeks back

                                      Ah. So its a placebo effect.

                                      • dmakk767
                                        dmakk767  1 weeks back

                                        Buy local food!

                                        • Sameer Athaley
                                          Sameer Athaley  1 weeks back

                                          Technically Organic is not correct word , it should Natural...There is difference between both...And natural is way better than organic...Forget about chemical

                                          • ZinZorius 312
                                            ZinZorius 312  2 days back

                                            Do you have any definitive proof to back up your claims?

                                        • Winston Funchannel
                                          Winston Funchannel  2 weeks back

                                          Love it!!!

                                          • FalseDusk
                                            FalseDusk  2 weeks back

                                            Video seems biased

                                          • Vishal Wankhede
                                            Vishal Wankhede  2 weeks back

                                            The solution is to reduce population

                                          • Midnight
                                            Midnight  2 weeks back

                                            I have nearly fully eliminated corn syrups from my diet. I keep under 25 added sugars a day. I try to eat high protien and healthy food.

                                            • Hanne Landbo
                                              Hanne Landbo  2 weeks back

                                              Some good points, but very disappointed in this video. Glyphosate etc might be the biggest obstacle to human health. You should check who funded the studies you are basing your research on.

                                            • cartucho da internet
                                              cartucho da internet  2 weeks back

                                              17100

                                              • adam lesonik
                                                adam lesonik  2 weeks back

                                                This is so misleading. Soooooooo much misinformation. So the makers of this video never heard of Monsanto? Thier pesticides are incredibly cancerous and almost single handedly wiped out the bees. Millions of people know this. These guys are corporate schills... no wonder thier videos pop up so often.

                                                • adam lesonik
                                                  adam lesonik  2 days back

                                                  @ZinZorius 312 Did you know the entire worlds nuclear energy is monopolised by 1 group? Thats why we do not have the incredible Thorium reactors everywhere. Also Monsanto has a somewhat similiar monopoly. But either way, even if you took Monsanto out of the picture, there is plenty of misinformation in the video.

                                                • ZinZorius 312
                                                  ZinZorius 312  2 days back

                                                  Not everyone that don't vehemently support organic food is a shill for Monsanto, just because one company is bad doesn't mean that everything in a whole field of science is bad.

                                                  It's like saying that nuclear energy is bad because nukes exist.

                                                • Emil Edlund
                                                  Emil Edlund  3 days back

                                                  Which pesticide?

                                              • harvaldi
                                                harvaldi  2 weeks back

                                                Organic or traditional farming supports more bio-diversity in nature. Industrial farming kills everything except one specie.

                                                • Tana
                                                  Tana  2 weeks back

                                                  Conventional produce has a bitter aftertaste that is not present in organic produce.
                                                  This is why the majority of the fine dining restaurants use organics.
                                                  Once you have been eating organically your taste buds will recognize the difference in most cases, especially if you are not a smoker or are not having alcohol with your meal.
                                                  I thought at first that my particularly sensitive taste buds were the reason I could tell the difference in multiple blind taste tests.
                                                  However, now that my husband has been eating organically grown foods for some time now he can easily tell the difference as well.
                                                  This video is not even close to being comprehensive concerning the pros and cons of organic vs. conventional.
                                                  Please do not take what is said here about a much more complicated and large topic that cannot be distilled and conveyed in less than 10 minutes as truth before you take the time to read much more extensively about this subject.
                                                  Regardless of what they are saying about organic foods here, your taste buds will not lie to you.

                                                  • Zhifu
                                                    Zhifu  2 weeks back

                                                    I Think he Should check Danmark. Danmark takes organic food serious and if u look up why you wil find out why organic is better

                                                    • Zhifu
                                                      Zhifu  2 days back

                                                      @ZinZorius 312 I Think you Should look it up on the internet

                                                    • ZinZorius 312
                                                      ZinZorius 312  2 days back

                                                      I live in Denmark and I don't know why/if organic is superior, care to explain?

                                                  • Quixzable
                                                    Quixzable  2 weeks back

                                                    Well in some cases that may be the case. But for example, my sister is alergic to most anti biotics. So in terms of meat she is bound to eat BIO/Organic meat since the day she almost died to a fucking steak. That actually made me personally lower my meat consume and so on since then. I'd rather go the saver route before just going with the cheap stuff. You never know what thing does what to you, atleast not percisely

                                                    • ZinZorius 312
                                                      ZinZorius 312  2 days back

                                                      That is only a problem for a small amount of people, just like the faact that a few people are allergic to vaccines doesn't make vaccines worse.

                                                  • patrick ledford
                                                    patrick ledford  2 weeks back

                                                    I always get organic strawberries because they are always sweeter but that’s about it

                                                    • JNOIRAMC
                                                      JNOIRAMC  2 weeks back

                                                      what do you think?? so you consider yourself.. inorganic..

                                                      • Evan Fabri
                                                        Evan Fabri  2 weeks back

                                                        This channel should change its name to "We are totally fucked, don't even try"

                                                        • Trina Renfroe
                                                          Trina Renfroe  2 weeks back

                                                          So summed up:
                                                          Organic food uses less energy, more land, usually less (but not always zero) pesticides, and nearly the same green house gasses
                                                          Conventional food uses more energy, less land, and normally more pesticides
                                                          Organic farmers use compost and manure, Conventional farmers also can but many times use processed fertilizer
                                                          The best thing for the environment is seasonal food since it is easily produced at the time
                                                          They both have mixed tests but organic *>can<* be better for health
                                                          Organic food is really people wanting to do the right and supposedly right thing for the environment

                                                          • Moon
                                                            Moon  2 weeks back

                                                            If school was like this....





                                                            I’d go everyday

                                                            • keko keko
                                                              keko keko  2 weeks back

                                                              Product from village: 5$
                                                              *ORGANIC* 15$

                                                              • Gustavo Hopkins
                                                                Gustavo Hopkins  2 weeks back

                                                                This didn't even look at it from a bacteria standpoint. Does one kill or promote the life in the soil, does one kill or promote bacterial life in the gut. Those two things have serious implications on a wide variety of issues like carbon intake, fertile soil production, mental and physical health and so on. The question shouldn't be is it good for us. It should be is it good for the microscopic life that are the true masters of this world

                                                                • Jayrome Babag
                                                                  Jayrome Babag  2 weeks back

                                                                  2:27
                                                                  Kurz: Is organic food more natural?

                                                                  Me: Hmmm...... yes the floor is made out of ground.

                                                                  • Jayrome Babag
                                                                    Jayrome Babag  2 weeks back

                                                                    Wanna hear something natural? Filtering weaknesses such as stupidity from the gene pool.

                                                                    • Greyscale / Greypool
                                                                      Greyscale / Greypool  2 weeks back

                                                                      Person: *Eats an apple*
                                                                      Bird: EAT MORE PEASANT *Basket chucks apples at them*

                                                                      • SMP STRONG
                                                                        SMP STRONG  2 weeks back

                                                                        Vinop

                                                                        • JB Floyd LeadValets
                                                                          JB Floyd LeadValets  2 weeks back

                                                                          I started eating organic and my allergies went away, lost a tone of weight and have felt better than I have in 30 years. That is my experience. My best suggestion, grow your own...